Home / Health / Junior doctors’ row: Government hit with second legal challenge over contracts

Junior doctors’ row: Government hit with second legal challenge over contracts

45A second legal challenge has been made over the government’s decision to impose a new contract

on junior doctors in England.

NHS staff campaign group Just Health started proceedings after raising £100,000 in four days online.

The move follows separate legal action made by the British Medical Association last week seeking a

judicial review.

The Department of Health said it was waiting to look at the details of the challenge before passing


The news comes two days before a planned 48-hour strike affecting routine and non-urgent care is

due to start.

The forthcoming strike will be the fourth time doctors have taken industrial action in the long-

running dispute.

Just Health alleges that government’s decision to impose the contract, affecting about 45,000

medics, did not allow for adequate consultation.

The group raised the £100,000 through a crowdfunding website which remains open to donations.

Dr Marie-Estella McVeigh, from Just Health, said: “We feel this contract imposition has been rushed

through without appropriate consideration and due process.

“There is no evidence that it will deliver a safer system or better quality care for our patients; it will

instead exacerbate the staffing crisis we are already struggling with across the NHS.”

The BMA, in its legal claim, alleges that the government failed to “pay due regard” to the equalities

impact of the new contracts and is calling for a judicial review.

Talks between the government and BMA broke down in January, prompting the government to

announce the following month that it would be imposing the contract in the summer.

Ministers have said the changes, which will see doctors paid less for working weekends, are needed

to improve care at weekends and create a “seven-day service”. This is disputed by the BMA.

Currently, junior doctors are paid more for working unsocial hours at night or at the weekend.

But under the imposed new contracts, the Saturday day shift will be paid at a normal rate in return

for a rise in basic pay.

Last month, the Department of Health described the forthcoming strike action by doctors as

“desperate and irresponsible”.