PMQs: Rishi Sunak challenged over early release of dangerous criminals

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has been challenged over the early release of dangerous criminals under a scheme aimed at easing overcrowding in jails.

During PMQs, Sir Keir Starmer asked for a guarantee that no criminals considered high risk were freed early.

The PM insisted no-one deemed a threat to public safety would be eligible.

But the Labour leader pointed to an example of one inmate who posed a danger to children, who had his release date brought forward.
The case was revealed in a report on HMP Lewes by the prisons watchdog, which was published on Tuesday.

The individual had a history of stalking and domestic abuse but was released without a full risk assessment.

The original scheme, introduced last October, allowed “low-level offenders” to be freed from prisons in England and Wales up to 18 days early under strict supervision.

This was increased to up to 60 days in March and will be further extended to up to 70 days from 23 May.

The government has said no-one convicted of a sexual, terrorist or serious violent offence would be eligible for early release.

The prison population has ballooned in recent decades as a result of tougher sentences and court backlogs.

Sir Keir said the government had not provided “basic details” about the scheme, including how many prisoners were being released early, where they were and what crimes they had committed.

He called for domestic abusers to be exempt from the scheme.

In response, Mr Sunak said: “There are strict eligibility criteria in place, with exclusions based on public safety and no-one will be put on the scheme if they were deemed a threat to public safety.”

The PM said prison governors also had “an absolute lock” over who was put on the scheme.

He added that those released were subject to strict conditions and supervision, which he said was in contrast to under the last Labour government.

Later, Downing Street denied the government was attempting to pass the buck onto prison governors in managing the move.

A Labour spokesman said the party would want to end the early release policy “as soon as possible” if it wins power, but added “we are under no illusion about the scale of the challenge we will face when it comes to the prison capacity crisis that we will inherit”.

Mr Sunak will be especially eager to maintain the Conservative Party’s reputation for being tough on crime in an election year.

Under repeated questioning from Sir Keir on the issue he hit back by arguing that the Conservatives believe more than Labour that prison prevents crime.

That attack line shows precisely why Mr Sunak is also now vulnerable if Labour can establish the argument in voters’ minds that prisoners are being released early who should not be on the streets.

In a piece of potentially awkward timing, one of the main pieces of legislation the government still hopes to complete before the general election is a Sentencing Bill.

The proposed law is partly intended to address the capacity problems by suspending almost all prison sentences of less than a year and expanding home detention.

But some prisons campaigners say this is insufficient to deal with the problems in the system, and in other ways the bill is designed to put people in prison longer – with those who commit the most violent murders imprisoned for life, and those sentenced for rape and some other sexual offences required to serve their whole sentence in prison, whereas currently they can in some circumstances be released on licence after two-thirds of the sentence.

Downing Street said the government was pressing ahead with the Sentencing Bill, adding: “In order to ensure that we can put the worst offenders away for longer we must make sure that there are sufficient spaces to lock up the most dangerous criminals.”

‘Serious concerns’
Chief inspector of prisons Charlie Taylor has raised “serious concerns” about the early release scheme.

His report highlighted one individual who had been freed early was recalled to custody before the watchdog’s inspection of the prison had ended.

According to the findings, the inmate had a “significant” drug problem and a record of self-harm as well as experiencing suicidal thoughts, but was freed despite “appeals for the decision to be reversed and staff having serious concerns for his and the public’s safety”.

Meanwhile, some court appearances in England will be delayed in another emergency measure to deal with prison overcrowding.

Under Operation Early Dawn, the Ministry of Justice says that it now needs to control the flow of cases reaching this first day in court because of the pressure on cells.

In practice, this means some defendants who would expect to be sent from court to a remand prison cell will be told the start of their case is being delayed. That will mean police will have to release some of them on bail with a date to later attend court.