No-deal Brexit poses serious risk to public safety, say police leaders

Exclusive: leaked letter warns home secretary of ‘significant loss of operational capacity’
A no-deal Brexit poses a substantial risk to public safety, with police officers instantly losing vital access to cross-border investigative powers and databases, the home secretary has been told in a damning letter from the national body of police and crime commissioners.
In the leaked document – marked “official sensitive” – the police leaders urge Sajid Javid to immediately draft contingency plans, warning that officers faced “a significant loss of operational capacity” should the UK crash out of the EU in March.
They say that they are becoming “increasingly concerned that such a loss of capacity could pose significant risks to our local communities”, and urge the home secretary to act swiftly to address their fears.
The letter from the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners (APCC) cross-party Brexit working group was after consultation with the National Crime Agency and the National Police Chiefs’ Council. The document expresses alarm that the government does not appear ready for such a crisis.
Over the weekend, the international trade secretary, Liam Fox, suggested that the UK now appeared poised to crash out of the EU owing to the “intransigence” of the Brussels machine. He put the chances of a no-deal Brexit at 60-40.
The European commission’s Brexit preparedness unit, operating under its German secretary general, Martin Selmayr, has already said it would “switch off the databases” if a deal was not struck in the coming months.
The APCC letter says British police make regular use of 32 different law enforcement and national security measures that depend on EU membership.
These include the European arrest aarrant – under which 1,735 arrests were made in the UK last year and more than 10,000 people were extradited since 2004 – and the Schengen information system (SIS), a vast database used by police to search for terrorist suspects, missing people and to check vehicle registrations and passport details. The SIS was checked 539m times by British officers in 2017.
The UK courts additionally depend on the European criminal records information system to establish the history of foreign offenders.
The crime commissioners say forces will need to spend extra time and money on “suboptimal” techniques to fight home-grown and foreign criminals unless a Brexit deal is struck.
The letter, signed by three commissioners representing the Conservatives, Labour and independents, says: “Considerable additional resource would be required for policing to operate using non-EU tools and that such tools would be suboptimal – potentially putting operational efficiency and public safety at risk.
“Recruitment, vetting and training of staff to use these tools would take a substantial amount of time.
“We are therefore concerned that a ‘no deal’ scenario could cause delays and challenges for UK policing and justice agencies.”
Advertisement
The EU and the UK have said they wanted to agree terms on a deal by the time of a leaders’ summit in Brussels in October, though the timescale appears increasingly optimistic.
The commissioners write that police forces would only have a “very challenging” five-month period in which to prepare for the loss of the EU-wide powers should such a deal not be achieved. They ask that the Home Office confirms that it “has developed effective contingency plans for a ‘no deal’ scenario”.
In the letter, they say: “These shared tools, measures, initiatives and capabilities which have been developed over the last 40 years of cooperation across the EU have saved many lives. We must find ways to protect these mutually important capabilities when the UK leaves the EU in order to ensure the safety and security all our citizens.”
Public service information notices are expected to be published imminently by the government on the need for citizens and businesses to prepare for a no-deal Brexit.
The release of 70 pamphlets over the summer was postponed after concerns that it would be seen as a political ploy to bolster the prime minister’s Chequers plan in which the UK would remain as a rule-taker in relation to standards on goods and rules on state aid.
The notices, when published, will come from the Department for Transport, which will advise on aviation, passports and driving licences for those travelling abroad.
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has been put in charge of contingency planning for the potential supply of animal-related products.
The Home Office is tasked with ensuring ensure that borders and immigration continue to be managed. The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy will seek to enforce contracts while the Department of Health will advise on the stockpiling of medicines.